No More Educational Kings!

No More Kings

(Guest post by Greg Forster)

Heading toward the Independence Day weekend, OCPA’s Perspective has just come out with my article on school choice as an embodiment of the principles of the Declaration of Independence:

The schools this country was founded upon saw themselves as responsible to families, churches, and, in a broad way, the local community. They were not government-owned or government-run…Government control over the minds of the young would have been seen by the founding generation as intolerable tyranny…

I argue that the creation of the government school monopoly involved a rejection of the principles of the founders, including religious freedom. One of the motives of Horace Mann and his Unitarian friends in creating a government school monopoly was to stamp out the old religion of the Puritans and establish Unitarianism in Massachusetts. Whatever you think of the relative merits of Calvinism and Unitarianism, government control of education for the purpose of religious indoctrination is not what this country was founded on.

Fortunately, by the time they tried to play this trick on another religious minority, the cat was out of the bag:

Thank heaven our Roman Catholic friends were smart enough to see what was going on when the government monopoly was turned against them. Not many Americans in the mid-19th century shared the Boston Brahmins’ contempt for evangelicals, but a lot of them did want to purge Catholic immigrants of their filthy popery. Catholics weren’t having any of it; in the great tradition handed down from the American founding, they ignored the government monopoly and started their own schools. America’s newcomers were more faithful to the principles of their adopted home than America itself was.

I not only support free speech but enjoy it, and I welcome your comments, whatever your view!

4 Responses to No More Educational Kings!

  1. matthewladner says:


  2. pbmeyer2014 says:

    Yes! This is why Tony Bryck et al titled their monumental study of Catholic schools, “The Common Good.” Catholic schools not only proved the American experiment a good one, they proved that it’s possible to give every child a good education.

  3. pdexiii says:

    I read this and realized it’s more history of education packed in this one article than any of my credential or Master’s classes at a historically Jesuit, JESUIT, institution. It indirectly confirms my theory of how our credentialing programs in the Golden State bow down to the altar of ‘inclusion,’ ‘diversity’ and ‘differentiation’ at the expense of knowledge and pedagogical skill so as to keep churning out credentials = raking in those tuition fees.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: